Business
USD $1.49 million bunker credit sleeving dispute between Goodwood and Southernpec reaches conclusion
Universal Alliance, BMS United, Digiland International, Goodwood Associates, Southernpec (Singapore), and Taigu Energy were involved in alleged circular fictitious trades of fuel oil during July 2015.
A High Court of the Republic of Singapore Judge on 5 November issued a reserved judgement over a bunker credit sleeving dispute between Goodwood Associates Pte Ltd (Goodwood), Southernpec (Singapore) Pte Ltd (SPPL), Southernpec (Singapore) Shipping Pte Ltd (SPSPL) and other individuals, according to a court document seen by Singapore bunker publication Manifold Times.
Summary
Singapore-based petrochemical wholesale company Goodwood was involved in a credit sleeve operation with several parties in July 2015, where it received a margin of USD 3 per metric tonne (mt) for its intermediary role to facilitate the sales of fuel oil between BMS United Bunkers (Asia) Pte Ltd (BMS) and SPPL.
Source: High Court of the Republic of Singapore
The transactions for 2,000 metric tonnes (mt) and 1,200 mt of fuel oil were supported by intertank transfer (ITT) certificates and cargo release notices (CRNs).
The Scheme was intended to comprise a circular chain of “back-to-back sales” of non-existent “fuel oil” from one entity in the chain to another lower down the chain, wrote Justice Hoo Sheau Peng.
To start the chain, BMS would provide actual funds to Universal Alliance Limited (UA), another oil trading company, which would then use the funds to make payment to the next fictitious “sub-seller” above it in the chain for an ostensible purchase of fictitious fuel oil, until the funds found their way back to BMS.
According to the view of SPPL’s Fuel Oil Trading Manager Jason Wu Jian Cai (Mr Wu), another motive of the circular fictitious “paper” deals in fuel oil was purportedly to help improve Goodwood’s revenue figures.
“Mr Wu brought the matter up to Mr Xu, who agreed to do so. This was because Mr Xu and Mr Wu had enjoyed a good working relationship with Mr Lee, Mr Lim and Dr Goh Jin Han (Dr Goh), the director and chief executive officer of Digiland, when the latter three were involved with another oil trading company IAG-Pacific Petroleum Pte Ltd.,” stated the court document, reflecting Mr Wu’s account of the alleged operation.
“To that end, Mr Lim came up with a scheme involving a circular series of fictitious trades (the Scheme) with BMS on board. In particular, Mr Lim introduced Mr Mohammad Arif bin Abdol Rahman (Mr Arif), a BMS bunker oil trader, who, according to Mr Wu, would “handle day-to-day running of the Scheme for BMS” with the blessing of his superior, Mr George Markos Kounalakis (Mr Kounalakis), the managing director of BMS.”
Dispute
Issues arose for the July contracts when UA defaulted on its payment to Taigu, which in turn did not pay SPPL; leading to SPPL’s default on its payment obligations to Goodwood.
As such, Goodwood launched a claim against purchaser SPPL for the two July fuel oil sales contracts; it is also claiming against SPSPL which is the guarantor of SPPL for the similar sales contracts.
Goodwood’s case was it had duly performed its obligations under the July Contracts as it relied on the ITT certificates and CRNs as supporting evidence for the transaction.
In response, both SPPL and SPSPL denied liability and claimed the two fuel oil sales contracts were shams; they issued a counterclaim against Goodwood and its associates on the grounds they were making legal claims on the false premise that the July Contracts were genuine.
Southernpec asserts the July Contracts are not enforceable due to them being “sham transactions supported by sham documents” and thus not being subjected to any legal effects.
SPSPL on November 2017 further introduced counterclaims against Goodwood and its associates for lawful and unlawful means conspiracy.
Goodwood on October 2018 started a counterclaim against SPPL for the purchase price based on the July Contracts.
Conclusion
In summary, Justice Hoo concluded the July contracts were not shams and dismissed SPPL’s and SPSPL’s claims based on the tort of conspiracy to injure and decided both were liable to Goodwood under the July Contracts and the SPSPL Guarantee respectively.
“Judgment is granted to Goodwood against SPPL and SPSPL in the sum of US$1,491,669.26 for the invoiced amounts under the July Contracts,” she stated.
“Contractual interest is awarded at the rate of 5.1885% per annum on US$932,177.08 from 30 July 2015 to the date of payment, and at the rate of 5.19075% per annum on US$559,492.18 from 4 August 2015 to the date of payment.”
Note: Full details of the 73-page judgement, including names of all staff involved and further details of the alleged credit sleeving operations, can be found on the original document available from the High Court website here.
Photo credit: Manifold Times
Published: 24 November, 2020
Milestone
Singapore retains titles as Best Global Seaport and Best Seaport in Asia
Port of Singapore has been named the “Best Global Seaport” for the third consecutive year and the “Best Seaport in Asia” for the 35th time at the 2023 AFLAS Awards.
The Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore on Friday (29 September) said the Port of Singapore has been named the “Best Global Seaport” for the third consecutive year and the “Best Seaport in Asia” for the 35th time at the 2023 Asian Freight, Logistics and Supply Chain (AFLAS) Awards.
These accolades recognise the contributions by the Port of Singapore serving as a key node in the global supply chain, and Singapore’s leadership in driving maritime decarbonisation and transformation.
The annual AFLAS Awards is organised by freight and logistics publication, Asia Cargo News, to honour leading service providers in the supply chain community for demonstrating leadership as well as consistency in service quality, innovation, customer relationship management and reliability. Winners were determined by votes cast by readers of the publication.
Mr Chee Hong Tat, Acting Minister for Transport and Senior Minister of State for Finance, said: “Singapore is honoured to be named the Best Global Seaport and Best Seaport in Asia. These awards are the result of the shared effort and strong collaboration between the Government, industry, unions and workers. We will continue to grow our port as an efficient, sustainable, and trusted node in global supply chains.”
Mr Teo Eng Dih, Chief Executive of MPA, said: “These awards are testament to the partnership and collaboration between Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA) with industry and international partners, the research and enterprise community, as well as unions. MPA remains committed to fostering an environment that encourages enterprise, innovation, and talent development.”
“We will continue to work with our partners to enhance Singapore’s connectivity, advance digitalisation efforts, and accelerate the decarbonisation of international shipping in line with the 2023 IMO strategy on reduction of GHG emissions from ships.”
Photo credit: Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore
Published: 29 September, 2023
Employment
Melvin Lum appointed as KPI OceanConnect Global Accounts Commercial Director in Singapore
Lum will take on the position of Commercial Director from Thomas Lee who was recently promoted to Head of APAC in a management restructure within KPI OceanConnect.
Biofuel
TotalEnergies Marine Fuels renews ISCC EU certification for bio bunker fuel
Firm’s operations teams in Singapore and Geneva successfully renewed its ISCC EU sustainability certification for the supply of biofuel bunkers, says Louise Tricoire, Vice President.
OUR INDUSTRY PARTNERS
Singapore retains titles as Best Global Seaport and Best Seaport in Asia
Melvin Lum appointed as KPI OceanConnect Global Accounts Commercial Director in Singapore
TotalEnergies Marine Fuels renews ISCC EU certification for bio bunker fuel
Seapath, Pilot LNG launch JV to develop dedicated LNG bunkering facility in US Gulf Coast
Bureau Veritas on biofuels: The transitional bunker fuel of today?
Ponant expedition yacht takes on B100 biodiesel bunker fuel in France
ENGINE: Americas Bunker Fuel Availability Outlook (28 Sep 2023)
Singapore: Maritime Census 2023 survey deadline extended to 23 October
GCMD, BCG survey highlights three maritime decarbonisation archetypes
Itochu enters MoU with firms for study of ammonia bunkering safety for container carrier
World Fuel Singapore Holding Company I to be wound up voluntarily, creditors to submit claims
Maersk and Equinor ink agreement for supply of green methanol bunker fuel
Singapore: Consort Bunkers and partners to develop ammonia bunkering tanker
VPS reiterates importance of understanding nature of biofuels, before mass adoption as bunker fuel for shipping
MOL and Shell Marine Products Singapore team up on developing green bunker fuels
Expert shares insights on ammonia’s toxicity as a bunker fuel
DNV Decarbonisation Insights: Speed up energy transition, shipping industry must move faster towards net zero goal
Study highlights emissions reduction of e1 Marine’s methanol to hydrogen fuel cell tech
DNV ‘Maritime Forecast to 2050’ report examines shipping’s energy future and role of technology in energy transition
Singapore: Equatorial Marine Fuel launches sustainable energy business unit, commits towards multi-fuel future
-
Business3 weeks agoWorld Fuel Singapore Holding Company I to be wound up voluntarily, creditors to submit claims
-
Methanol3 weeks agoMaersk and Equinor ink agreement for supply of green methanol bunker fuel
-
Newbuilding3 weeks agoSingapore: Consort Bunkers and partners to develop ammonia bunkering tanker
-
Alternative Fuels3 weeks agoVPS reiterates importance of understanding nature of biofuels, before mass adoption as bunker fuel for shipping
-
Alternative Fuels3 weeks agoMOL and Shell Marine Products Singapore team up on developing green bunker fuels
-
Ammonia3 weeks agoExpert shares insights on ammonia’s toxicity as a bunker fuel
-
Decarbonisation2 weeks agoDNV Decarbonisation Insights: Speed up energy transition, shipping industry must move faster towards net zero goal
-
Bunker Fuel3 weeks agoStudy highlights emissions reduction of e1 Marine’s methanol to hydrogen fuel cell tech
