The North P&I Club on Monday (12 April) published an article outlining some considerations and frequently asked questions about switching to biofuel to comply with future environmental regulations; it was written by Mark Smith, Loss Prevention Executive:
Achieving the IMO’s goals on greenhouse gas emissions will require a shift in how vessels are fuelled and propelled. Amongst the options available to shipowners on meeting the IMO targets, lower-carbon fuels are likely to be a popular option – one of which is biofuels.
Switching to biofuels could be an attractive proposition to some shipowners. The conversion to biofuels – whether a blend or ‘drop-in’ (replacement) fuel – is relatively simple. Ships’ engines and transfer and storage systems will require minimal modifications from using traditional marine (fossil) fuel. The lack of availability and higher costs have been identified as barriers to adoption, but there could be positive shifts in this area too.
North has already received enquiries from shipowners who are considering using biofuels, indicating interest is growing and the shipping industry is keen to know more. We spoke to Bart Hellings and Johannes Schurmann from biofuel provider GoodFuels based in the Netherlands for expert insight.
How do biofuels compare with fossil fuels?
Just like fossil fuels there are multiple types of biofuels and they can also differ on sulphur, density, and viscosity parameters. The heaviest marine biofuel which GoodFuels supply is MR1-100 which compares to RMD-80. Different biofuels which are closer to other product categories are also available.
How does ISO 8217:2017 cater for the latest biofuels?
It’s important to remember that ISO 8217 is a fossil fuel standard; and while it could be used as a guideline, there are missing parameters that are relevant to biofuels and others which are no longer relevant.
Are biofuels susceptible to microbial growth and what about their shelf life?
They normally contain less than 0.05% (v/v) water which is very low. Microbial growth normally occurs when water is added to the fuel by condensation or poor housekeeping on the ship. This risk is reduced by storing in a clean fuel tank and preventing water ingress. Special additives have been developed if microbial activity is a concern and specific operational procedures will be required.
Some biofuels undergo processes where oxygen is eliminated and are perhaps even more resistant to microbial growth in terms of quality and have at least the same shelf life of fossil fuels.
How is the quality of the biofuel assured?
Poor quality biofuels can be very diverse in their content and characteristics. GoodFuels have found that the following helps with the overall quality:
How is biofuel quality and conformity proven?
A certificate of analysis (CoA) will confirm that specifications have been met and a sustainability certificate will verify the fuel is produced from sustainable feedstocks.
The last year has shown there is higher risk of stability and compatibility issues with VLSFOs – how do biofuels compare?
Tried and tested biofuels do not appear to cause customers any more issues than fossil fuels. The issues experienced with VLSFOs have not been reported with their marine biofuels.
Are there any special tank cleaning requirements?
There are no reported problems regarding stability and compatibility when leftover fossil fuels remain in the tank. However, thorough cleaning of fuel tanks prior to use of biofuels will prevent operational problems caused by fossil fuel sediment entering the fuel system.
What do the engine makers say?
GoodFuels has carried out extensive testing of biofuels with the top five original equipment makers (OEMs). They are now very supportive of GoodFuels’ biofuels and additional OEMs are ratifying our products on a constant basis.
What is the future of biofuels?
Advanced marine biofuels are a fast-growing alternative fuel in the marine sector. July 2020 was a record month with biofuels representing 10% of all Rotterdam HFO volumes. We expect growth to continue for this low-sulphur ‘drop-in’ fuel which can be used in existing engines with a significant CO2 reduction.
The shipping industry needs to keep its guard up. Shipowners and fuel purchasers should ensure that they are supplied only with sustainably sourced, high quality and stable products. GoodFuels can only vouch for the quality of their own products and regularly see bad quality biofuels from other suppliers with less stringent quality controls.
Poor quality-controlled biofuels can create operational issues and potential damage to main engines and generators. High repair costs not to mention the delays to cargo, commercial off-hire and lengthy disputes with charterers are all concerns. In rare cases de-bunkering may be required too.
How does NOx, calorific value and fuel consumption compare to fossil fuels?
The effect on NOx is still uncertain, but testing is underway together with clients, OEMs and classification societies. Calorific value can be lower than fossil fuels and therefore the fuel consumption may be slightly higher.
Photo credit: GoodFuels
Source: North P&I
Published: 13 April, 2021
BunkerEx, which observes over 2,000 marine fuel prices per day, integrates bunker pricing data in ZeroNorth’s platform, Optimise.
Finds ‘Preparing Container Vessels for Conversion to Green Fuels’ report published by Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller Center for Zero Carbon Shipping.
The 190,000 tonnes ship “UBUNTU HARMONY” was independently developed and designed by Shanghai Waigaoqiao Shipbuilding Co., Ltd and delivered to U-Ming Marine Transport.
‘More research is required to understand the best options (fuel or energy carrier) for individual industrial applications’, says Executive Vice President in SINTEF.
Destinations for the marine fuel included Hong Kong, Malaysia and Singapore in five cargo shipments, said company spokesperson Ely Chandra Perangiangin.
MOL Drybulk, Oshima Shipbuilding, and Iknow Machinery has formed an agreement to develop a sail that can be mounted on ships' cargo handling cranes.
‘Economics of the shipping market will be the key driver enabling methanol to be adopted at a higher pace going forth over next couple years as market begins to return to more normal rates,’ states COO.
Integr8 Fuel injunction varied by Singapore Court to allow former employees to start work at Hartree Group in December 2022 following failure to produce evidence on biofuels development plans.
Variability of sources can affect the stability and performance of biofuel bunkers produced from these feedstocks, in turn leading to difficulties in meeting regulations and industry standards, shares Bryan Quek.
Top three positive movers in 2022 were Bunker House Petroleum Pte Ltd (+7), Eastpoint International Marketing Pte Ltd (+5), and Eng Hua Company (Pte) Ltd (+6); newcomer Sinopec Fuel Oil (Singapore) gets 19th spot.
Livestock carrier also involved in earlier bunker claim with Glander International Bunkering due to remaining unpaid fuel bill of approximately USD 116,000, according to court documents obtained by Manifold Times.
A blend of standard MGO and biodiesel, MGO B20 is distributed at the company’s floating kiosk CNC 5 which is located off the buoy of West Coast Pier; PS Energy has been stamped with globally recognised ISCC.
