Wärtsilä: Long live the internal combustion engine
Maritime technology group Wärtsilä published an article analysing the internal combustion engine’s flexibility to to adapt using alternative fuels and achieving environmental targets; it was written by Alexander Farnsworth:
The internal combustion engine stands out as one invention that has transformed every facet of human life. Over a hundred years after its invention, it still stands tall as the primary driver of industry and transportation across the globe.
Yet, as the world grapples with the effects of climate change, there are concerns about the internal combustion engine’s contribution to global warming. Historically, improvements to the design have focussed on maximising its power and torque, with little innovation when it comes to improving its eco-credentials. But this trend is changing, and fast. That has a lot to do with how ubiquitous it is especially in the maritime industry.
“There are not many viable alternatives to the internal combustion engine,” declares Lucien Koopmans, Professor and Head of Division for Combustion and Propulsion Systems at Chalmers University, Sweden. “Electric motors are an option where minimising emissions and particulate matter is important – in regulated areas, entering and exiting harbours – but giving up cargo space, and weight, for battery space is the big issue if longer distances need to be covered.”
“We still need the internal combustion engine. It’s the best we have in our path towards sustainable shipping. In fact, it is possible today to power a ship and have close to zero emissions with today’s alternative energy and clean-burning solutions,” claims Fredrik Östman, General Manager Wärtsilä Marine Business, Strategy & Business Development.
How can this be done? The trick, says experts, is to find a way to reduce greenhouse gases emitted by these engines through the use of alternative fuels, and smarter, more efficient means of combustion.
Improving upon established designs
“Our focus is to optimise the efficiency of the combustion processes as much as we possibly can, together with various low carbon fuels like biofuels, ammonia, hydrogen and methanol,” explains Östman. “Applying these kinds of minute and advanced controls to the combustion process has only been possible in the last decade or so with advances in combustion control and computer modelling.”
As the climate debate has heated up, more research has been applied to studying the minutia of the actual combustion process down to the atomic level, and what happens to different fuels and their thermal efficiencies when combusted at different pressures and physical states.
“As computer power has become cheaper and more sophisticated, much of our efforts focus on modelling combustion parameters like turbulence and chaos with different fuels and application types, like spray and atomisation in order to increase the thermal efficiency (output/input) of engines big and small. And usually, the bigger the engine, the higher efficiency you can get,” says Koopmans.
The holy grail is reaching 60 percent efficiency, according to Koopmans, which isn’t too far off. Wärtsilä holds a Guinness Book of World Records title for its Wärtsilä 31 engine, the most efficient 4-stroke diesel engine in the world, with more than 50 percent fuel efficiency.
“It really boils down to an economic argument. Will there ever be a fuel as cheap as HFO? Every alternative we know of requires a lot of expensive processes to make them viable for combustion at scale. Since the supply of biofuels will be limited, industries like aviation with a capability to pay more for the fuel will likely gobble up whatever is available.”
But says Östman: “Economics is indeed important, but the price of HFO is irrelevant if there is emission legislation in place that forces the industry to move towards alternative fuels. So given strict emission regulation on green-house gases, the relative cost of the alternative fuels is what will be important.”
The search for alternative solutions
One fuel that is gaining traction worldwide, however, is liquefied natural gas, or LNG, with bunkering facilities currently being built around the world to harness dual-fuel (DF) capabilities.
“There is nothing that the internal combustion engine does with HFO that cannot be done with LNG,” says Östman. “LNG contains no sulphur, making compliance a piece of cake. The reality is that the combustion engine really doesn’t care about the fuel. As long as it burns, we can use it in our engines.”
“Carbon-neutral fuels like synthetic LNG seems today to be the most economically viable for the shipping industry to become sustainable. But at the same, it’s also clear that there will be a large palette of fuels with large local variations in availability. So, what we need to focus on is fuel flexibility. Testing different fuels is a core element of our business, which we continuously do. A large set of various biofuels, hydrogen and methanol have been tested for years in our engines. We’re currently also investigating what it means to use ammonia as a fuel. What strikes us time and time again is that the combustion engine is extremely fuel flexible and only minor changes are needed to adapt it to new fuels. A lot of the needed infrastructure is already in place, the technology is mature and safe, and we have the needed regulations in place – along with years of experience!”
While work finding cleaner fuels and exotic new technologies continues, it is clear that it is the internal combustion engine that will remain the mainstay of the maritime industry. And with efforts to improve its efficiency continuing, it is the best placed to enable the transition to the low-emission future that the sector is desperately searching for.
“The combustion engine remains the stalwart of shipping because it enables fuel flexibility leaving the doors wide open for the future renewable liquid and gaseous fuels as and when they become compliant, market-ready and available,” says Östman.
Photo credit: Wärtsilä
Published: 9 March, 2020.
SEA\LNG introduces Bunker Navigator Tool
Online tool provides access to the latest developments in the global LNG bunkering infrastructure.
Cargill and partners launch maritime decarbonisation program in Singapore
With ten other industry leaders, it aims to unite startups and industry players to test transformational technologies that reduce CO2 emissions.
EU funding boosts vessel fuel efficiency mission of SeaTech consortium
Developing ultra-high energy conversion and renewable energy propulsion to lower emissions and bunker costs.
MOL teams up with NMRI on engine digital twin model development
Research aims to create a visual twin model for optimisation, engine operating state monitoring and engine failure diagnosis.
DNV GL: Green technologies enhance efficiency of shuttle tankers
LNG dual-fuel shuttle tankers demonstrate environmental sustainability and operational flexibility are commercially viable.
Bulugo launches digital platform to simplify marine fuels and lubs procurement
Platform designed to help industry navigate uncertainties in sourcing fuel and lubricants while reducing time and costs.
Trefoil appoints Inatech to cope with Dutch ‘double whammy’ of IMO2020 risks
Faced with higher risks resulting from IMO2020 and new stringent audit regulations, Trefoil seeks fully integrated system solution to maximise efficiency.
Dataloy integrates with BunkerPlanner to optimise bunker procurement
Advanced algorithms to help today’s shipping industry navigate strategic bunker sourcing, cost optimisation, and bunker procurement.
rise-x.io, DNV GL, NUS embark on project to predict illegal bunker activity
Though computer models analysing automatic identification system data to determine if illegal fuel bunkering can be detected using vessel pattern analysis.
BH Global and partners set to develop Singapore’s first hybrid electric marine launch
Homegrown companies pave the way forward in commercialising marine hybrid propulsion technologies to reduce carbon emissions.
WinGD Flexible Injector Concept research expands clean fuel candidates for ships
Company’s foray into designing a Flexible Injector aims to provide solutions to handle a full spectrum of fuels to future proof the uncertainty of industry regulations for clean fuel.
Monaco Marfin Management partners BunkerTrace to enhance bunkering transparency
BunkerTrace tracks marine fuel using synthetic DNA markers at specific points of the supply chain and records each transaction in a blockchain-based solution.
Wärtsilä launches LNG Bunkering & Fuel Supply System Simulator to raise training levels
Simulator design is based on Wärtsilä LNGPac and Gas Valve Unit technologies, and in accordance with the STCW requirements demanded by the international code of safety.
DNV GL grants statement of compliance to Rivertrace SMART ESM washwater monitor for scrubbers
SMART ESM monitors regulated water quality parameters PAH, Turbidity, Temperature and pH, on open-loop, closed-loop and hybrid scrubber systems.
ABB presents recommendation for zero-emission marine technology to US Congress
‘ABB encourages the Subcommittee to set an ambitious, long-term national plan to achieve zero emissions for all vessels under its operation,’ says Peter Bryn.
Maersk Tankers launches standalone digital business product SimBunker
SimBunker optimises vessels’ bunker spend by determining factors such as speed, bunker purchase, route.
Ascenz enhances vessel monitoring solution with Inmarsat agreement
Shipulse solution now an Inmarsat Certified application that is integrated with Inmarsat’s network capabilities.
CSA 2020 members share scrubber installation tips to shipowners
Recommends use of quality, high-end materials after experience from more than 1,500 EGCS installations.
Shipping industry proposes $5 billion R&D fund to reduce emissions
Maritime associations representing 90% of world merchant fleet submits R&D programme proposal to IMO.
MARINTEC – Chinese yard to build fuel saving bulk carrier and VLCC
Silverstream air lubrication system able to save between 5-10% of fuel for vessels depending on characteristics.
CSSC Marine Service offers engine start solution for LS fuels
Some two-stroke engines using common-rail injection report issues when using less viscous low-sulphur fuels.
Bunker fuel quality monitoring solution among winners at PIER71 event
‘It has been an exhilarating experience being part of Smart Port Challenge,’ said Dravam CEO & Founder.
Stena Line AI technology pilot reduces fuel consumption
Fleet wide installation of ‘Stena Fuel Pilot’ and will be carried out on all 37 vessels in Europe during 2020.
BunkerTrace fuels tracking solution starts commercial launch
Solution adds DNA markers to fuel at every stage of supply chain and records transactions in blockchain system.
Victory Petroleum increases administrative productivity with e-Data Logger
‘We are currently the only bunker supplier using an e-Data Logger application,’ shares spokeswoman.
BIMCO introduces monitoring service for bunker prices for members
Interactive graphs allow price fluctuations at major bunkering hubs of Singapore and Rotterdam to be tracked.
Singapore: Earlier court judgement between Hanwa and Harley Marine discharged
Hanwa obtained judgement following an “Emergency Arbitration” application on 18 July 2018 to prevent the risk of dissipation by the former Singapore-based bunkering firms.
BP Singapore bunker trial nears end as legal reps present summary submissions
Lawyers of the ex-Regional Marine Manager of BP Singapore, the Executive Director of Pacific Prime Trading, and Deputy Public Prosecutors were present at the State Courts on Wednesday.
Vitol Group acquires Sinanju Tankers Holdings; gains foothold in Singapore bunker ops
The Singapore Bunkering license holding entity has been renamed Vitol Bunkers (S) Pte Ltd and from 1 April 2020 all bunker deliveries will be carried out by Vitol Bunkers (S) Pte Ltd.
PMI Trading responds to Nustar Energy over alleged off-spec bunker fuel supply at Houston
Seeks to enforce either arbitration clause under contract or to dismiss NuStar and TPP respective liability claims, according to documents obtained by Manifold Times.
‘Minimal disruption’ to Singapore bunkering operations despite COVID-19, confirms MPA
‘We are closely monitoring the rapidly developing COVID-2019 situation while remaining committed to working with the bunkering industry to ensure minimal disruption to bunkering operations and services.’
Photo Essay: “Marine Vicky” in multi-agency emergency preparedness exercise at Singapore port
The emergency preparedness exercise involving SCDF, PCG, MPA, and Sinanju was carried out on the LNG dual-fuel bunker tanker at Raffles Anchorage on 17 March, learned Manifold Times.