Jim Leighton, the Senior Solicitor England and Wales, Freight, Demurrage and Defense (FD&D) at the North P&I Club has written an article to remind stakeholders to pay close attention on all clauses in a charterparty that stipulate time bars. The following is part of the whole article:
Lukoil Asia v Ocean Tankers, the “Ocean Neptune”
The “Ocean Neptune”  EWHC 163 (Comm) serves as an important reminder that close attention needs to be paid to demurrage claim presentation time bars. Such time bars also present the risk of an owner being caught out on less conventional claims concerning the delay of the vessel while awaiting a charterer’s orders.
In this case the vessel called at three ports to discharge the cargo. But following a cargo quality dispute arising at the first port of discharge, it was subjected to a stay in excess of 1,000 hours. The charterer had, in accordance with its contractual rights, ordered the vessel to wait off the first port of discharge pending confirmation of further orders.
Unfortunately, the cargo was never accepted by the receiver at the first port of discharge. The cargo was later discharged in a more usual time frame at the second and third ports of discharge, before completing the contractual voyage. The owner then presented its claim within the demurrage claim presentation time bar period.
However, the owner did not comply with some of the documentary presentation requirements for the conventional demurrage claim, for time used during cargo operations in port. The High Court, in agreement with the arbitrators, decided that this demurrage claim failed for want of compliance.
Nevertheless, the arbitrators allowed the delay claim while awaiting the charterer’s orders on the premise that there were no documents identified, or that needed to be presented, by the relevant clauses for that aspect of the claim to succeed. The High Court did not agree, so dismissed the delay claim too.
The High Court decision was made on the basis that the delay awaiting the charterer’s orders was to “count as” time on demurrage. As that was inherently tied up with the demurrage clauses in general, including the time bar, the decision time barred what would otherwise have been a true detention claim.
This case can be contrasted with The “Seagrace”  EWHC 156 (Comm). The charterparty clauses in this case did not give the charterer a right to order the vessel to await orders. The parties agreed a delay awaiting orders would be allowed at the demurrage rate. However, this did not result in the demurrage claim presentation time bar barring what in this case was a true detention claim.
A key point to take away from these cases is that whether or not a demurrage claim presentation time bar is effective against other claims that are not of a conventional demurrage nature, depends on the careful reading of the charterparty in question. As such, an owner should check all demurrage clauses, including related time bars, carefully in each case.
The full article can be found here.
The above article is related to earlier news stories below concerning time bars:
Published: 9 October, 2018
The newly launched Code of Best Practices – Commodity Financing guidelines will be the new ‘reference point’ taken by banks when considering to give trade finance to trading houses, believes Ian Teo.
Captain Daknash Ganasen, Senior Director (Operations & Marine Services), MPA, provides direction on what should players do when providing bunker fuel to a COVID-19 infected ship, and more.
Garren Hay will be responsible for sales of the PANOLIN range of Environmentally Acceptable Lubricants for the Singapore sole distributor agent Gealubes Consulting & Trading Pte Ltd.
Universal Alliance, BMS United, Digiland International, Goodwood Associates, Southernpec (Singapore), and Taigu Energy were involved in alleged circular fictitious trades of fuel oil during July 2015.
Bunker orders of ISO 8217:2010 spec LS 380 cSt 0.5% for Nord Gemini, Nord Titan, Ocean Rosemary, and Luzern were placed through global commodities trading and logistics house Trafigura Pte Ltd.
While Covid-19 concerns are important, Captain Rahul Choudhuri was quick to note this does not mean bunker fuel related issues have indeed disappeared from the shipping sector.