An Liberia-flagged oil tanker, Fair Star, was arrested in Singapore waters on Saturday (5 October). 

The vessel was added to the list of vessels under Sheriff’s arrest in Singapore’s court system. 

According to the list, the vessel was arrested at 9.05pm and the arresting solicitor listed was law firm Rajah & Tann Singapore LLP. The ship is currently held at Eastern Petroleum Anchorage A. 

No details regarding the reason behind the arrest were provided in the list. 

 

Photo credit: MarineTraffic / Flare
Published: 9 October, 2024

Law firm Reed Smith on Thursday (26 September) shared comments of its transportation lawyers Han Deng and Alice Colarossi on the Baltimore bridge collision incident involving Singapore-registered vessel “Dali” in March:

Several claims have been filed against the owners and managers of the cargo ship in the aftermath of the incident, including (among others), on September 18, 2024, a USD 100 million claim by the U.S. Department of Justice, which alleged that the collapse was caused by the “outrageous, grossly negligent, willful, wanton, and reckless” conduct of the owners and operators, who they allege sent out an unseaworthy and poorly maintained vessel with a history of equipment failures to navigate a critical waterway.  

The government opposes the petition that was filed by the owners and managers of the vessel to limit their liability to approximately USD 44 million under the U.S. Limitation of Liability Act—a U.S. statute dating back to 1851 that allows ship owners to limit their total liability to the value of the vessel and pending freight after major incidents (while the Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims does not apply in the United States).

The lawsuit raises a number of legal and factual issues, including as to the owners’ and managers’ knowledge of the condition of the vessel, and the circumstances and causes of the incident.

At the Port of Baltimore, ships are typically required to have a harbor pilot on board when navigating through the harbor and approaching or leaving the port. This is a common rule in many U.S. ports to ensure safe passage through waterways, such as crowded harbors or narrow canals. 

It requires tugs to assist ships in and out the port but does not mandatorily require extended escorts into the port’s channel or further into the bay. Tug escorts are only required in Baltimore for specific cargo types like oil or liquid natural gas, and for docking and undocking operations of larger ships with limited maneuverability. 

Harbor pilots or the ship’s operator can request extra tug services if and when they have safety concerns. Two harbor pilots were temporarily in charge of navigating the DALI on her exit from the Port of Baltimore.

Two tugboats also initially guided the ship out of the dock and then left the ship when she was safely inside the channel 20 minutes before the collapse. Minutes before hitting one of the bridge supports, the pilot called for tug assist, but it was too late.

The incident raises questions about safety measures for large ships passing under bridges, including whether additional tugboat escorts could prevent such accidents. Some have advocated for new regulations requiring tug escorts, changing protocols for tug escorts or standardizing escort rules across ports.

The rules currently vary depending on the port and state, and there are currently no harmonized tug escort requirements at the U.S. federal level, except in certain safety zones and for certain tankers. This could change. Note that there are no confirmed new regulations requiring towboat escorts for ships leaving the Port of Baltimore as a result of the collapse.

Implementing such new regulations could introduce complications, such as delays and additional costs.  Further insights may emerge from ongoing investigations, including a report from the National Transportation Safety Board, which could address the feasibility and potential benefits of towboat escorts in preventing similar incidents.

Related: FBI boards Singapore-flagged ship “Maersk Saltoro” in Baltimore
Related: US sues owner, operator of Singapore-registered “Dali” for Baltimore bridge crash
Related: NTSB report dismisses bunker fuel as cause of Singapore-registered “Dali” crashing into Baltimore bridge
Related: Baltimore bridge crash: Safety investigation to include contaminated bunker fuel as possible cause
Related: Baltimore bridge collapse: FuelTrust highlights bunkering activities of Singapore-registered “Dali”
Related: MPA: Singapore-registered ship in Baltimore bridge crash passed previous foreign port state inspections

 

Photo credit: Baltimore County Fire Department
Published: 27 September, 2024 

US federal agents on Saturday (21 September) boarded a Singapore-flagged container ship managed by the same company as Singapore-registered container vessel Dali that crashed into the Francis Scott Key Bridge in March, according to several media outlets.

Citing a statement by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and US Attorney’s Office in Maryland, they confirmed several law enforcement agencies including FBI agents boarded Maersk Saltoro in the Port of Baltimore. 

Both Maersk Saltoro and Dali are managed by Singapore-based Synergy Marine Group.

“The Federal Bureau of Investigation, US Environmental Protection Agency’s Criminal Investigation Division and Coast Guard Investigative Services are present aboard the Maersk Saltoro conducting court authorised law enforcement activity,” said FBI and the US Attorney’s Office. 

Both did not provide further information. The development came just days after the Justice Department filed a civil claim in the US District Court for the District of Maryland against Grace Ocean and Synergy Marine, the Singaporean corporations that owned and operated the container ship that destroyed the bridge.

The suit seeks to recover over USD 100 million in costs the United States incurred in responding to the fatal disaster and for clearing the entangled wreck and bridge debris from the navigable channel so the port could reopen.

In a press call, Acting Deputy Assistant Attorney General Chetan Patil of the Civil Division said: “This accident happened because of the careless and grossly negligent decisions made by Grace Ocean and Synergy, who recklessly chose to send an unseaworthy vessel to navigate a critical waterway and ignored the risks to American lives and the nation’s infrastructure.”

The Straits Times reported that Synergy Marine Group has confirmed that US authorities have left the Maersk Saltoro to resume cargo operations on 22 September. 

Related: US sues owner, operator of Singapore-registered “Dali” for Baltimore bridge crash
Related: NTSB report dismisses bunker fuel as cause of Singapore-registered “Dali” crashing into Baltimore bridge
Related: Baltimore bridge crash: Safety investigation to include contaminated bunker fuel as possible cause
Related: Baltimore bridge collapse: FuelTrust highlights bunkering activities of Singapore-registered “Dali”
Related: MPA: Singapore-registered ship in Baltimore bridge crash passed previous foreign port state inspections

 

Photo credit: FBI Baltimore
Published: 24 September, 2024