Lawyers representing shipping firm Dampskibsselskabet NORDEN A/S (DS Norden) and Singapore bunker supplier Global Energy Trading Pte Ltd (Global) met at a pre-trial conference organised by the High Court of the Republic of Singapore on Tuesday (17 November) to discuss matters relating to a bunker claim, according to documents obtained by the Singapore bunkering publication Manifold Times.
Claim by Dampskibsselskabet NORDEN
DS Norden was seeking for a total claim of USD 2 million (exact: USD 2,066,063.03) and SGD 22,000 (exact: SGD 22,283.00) from Global over loss and damages from the supply of alleged off-spec low sulphur 380 centistokes (cSt) 0.5% bunker fuel to Nord Gemini, Nord Titan, Ocean Rosemary, and Luzern at Singapore port in or around January 2020.
About 997.985 metric tonnes (mt) of the material was delivered to Nord Gemini on 4 January; 359.102 mt to Nord Titan on 17 Janaury; 1,196.303 mt to Ocean Rosemary on 21 January, and 498.407 mt to Luzern on the same day (21 Janaury).
“The Bunkers supplied and/or delivered by the Defendant were unusable (in fact worse than unusable given that they were potentially or actually damaging to the respective Vessels’ engines) and the Plaintiff is entitled to the return of the price paid on a total failure of consideration and/or in restitution,” alleged lawyers in DS Norden’s statement of claim.
The bunker orders were placed through global commodities trading and logistics house Trafigura Pte Ltd., according to the documents. The orders under the ISO 8217:2010 fuel quality standard specified a maximum sulphur content of 0.50% and Total Sediment Potential (TSP) limit of 0.10% amongst other parameters.
An initial fuel analysis conducted by the owners of the four vessels after respective bunker deliveries found fuel samples to be off-spec.
Subsequent joint analysis conducted by Trafigura, DS Norden and the owners of the four vessels claimed an excessive TSP level for the bunkers supplied and delivered by Global; in addition, fuel delivered to the Luzern had excessive sulphur levels.
Defence of Global Energy Trading
Lawyers representing Global stated: “Any remedy DS Norden may have lies in a contractual claim against Trafigura, which DS Norden is actively pursuing against Trafigura through arbitration proceedings in London.”
They added there was no duty of care by Global to DS Norden, amongst other arguments.
“There is altogether no basis for any claim (in negligence or otherwise) by DS Norden against Global,” the lawyers explained.
“DS Norden’s attempt to found a claim in negligence against Global is an attempt to circumvent its contractual bargain with Trafigura.
“DS Norden chose to contract with Trafigura rather than Global, and should not be allowed to better its bargain and sidestep the risk exposure negotiated and agreed between parties. In the premises, the present claim is frivolous, vexatious, and an abuse of court process.”
Further tests of bunker samples conducted by Global with a SAC-SINGLAS Accredited Laboratory later revealed the following results:
**Test results not shared in court document
Testing done on the samples obtained at the time of delivery and retained by Global indicated the bunkers supplied to Nord Gemini, Ocean Rosemary and Nord Titan conformed to the specification required by the Bunker Standards and Regulations, said lawyers.
In summary, Global’s legal team stated, amongst others, that:
DS Norden’s present claim against Global is an attempt to circumvent:
“Global denies DS Norden is entitled to any of the reliefs claimed,” they stated.
Photo credit: Manifold Times
Published: 20 November, 2020
KPI OC seeking to recover debt of USD 805,602.15 over five bunker deliveries, not including accrued interest of about USD 363,000 since 15 September, showed court documents obtained by Manifold Times.
Discussions around the need to develop methanol bunkering operations are taking place at numerous ports ahead of estimated demand of above 7M mtpa by 2030, says Chris Chatterton of Methanol Institute.
‘Economics of the shipping market will be the key driver enabling methanol to be adopted at a higher pace going forth over next couple years as market begins to return to more normal rates,’ states COO.
Integr8 Fuel injunction varied by Singapore Court to allow former employees to start work at Hartree Group in December 2022 following failure to produce evidence on biofuels development plans.
Variability of sources can affect the stability and performance of biofuel bunkers produced from these feedstocks, in turn leading to difficulties in meeting regulations and industry standards, shares Bryan Quek.
Top three positive movers in 2022 were Bunker House Petroleum Pte Ltd (+7), Eastpoint International Marketing Pte Ltd (+5), and Eng Hua Company (Pte) Ltd (+6); newcomer Sinopec Fuel Oil (Singapore) gets 19th spot.