Legal representatives of DBS Bank (Hong Kong) Limited will be submitting an application to the High Court of the Republic of Singapore on Wednesday (21 April) to start a suit against Sinfeng Marine Services Pte Ltd (Sinfeng, or defendant), according to documents obtained by Singapore bunkering publication Manifold Times from the court.
The financial institute is seeking pre-action discovery, for the release of relevant documents between Sinfeng and the defunct bunkering firm Coastal Oil Singapore Pte Ltd. (Coastal Oil), to determine the type of legal action it should commence against Sinfeng going forward.
Background of DBS involvement with Coastal Oil
DBS Bank Hong Kong (DBS, or plaintiff) earlier issued a USD 30 million credit facility to Coastal Oil and is seeking to recover the debt.
It claims Sinfeng entered into five contracts with Coastal Oil between October to November 2018, where Coastal Oil assigned to DBS its receivables. However, Coastal Oil was shortly placed in creditors’ voluntary liquidation on 13 December 2018.
The bunkering firm owed approximately USD 357 million to 79 companies, of which USD 354 million was owed to major banks (including DBS).
‘Curious relationship’ between Sinfeng and Coastal Oil
DBS noted it has received reports from liquidators of Coastal Oil which indicate there may have been fraudulent conduct where executed documents were not genuine.
A liquidator report on 2 December 2019 revealed a trading loop between Sinfeng, Coastal Oil and Arkanata Yasa Trading Pte. Ltd. (Yasa) where the details are as follows:
The liquidator document further identified a former Coastal Oil Treasury Officer, who is currently facing 63 charges for allegedly creating fictitious sales contracts and submitting them to banks in order to obtain financing, placing Yasa as an end-buyer.
Further, the same report stated invoices issued to Sinfeng between July to December 2018 being accompanied by the Bunker Delivery Note issued by PT Farma Kimia Distribution, which is an unknown entity that the liquidators have not been able to locate or contact.
“At the bare minimum, the abovementioned circumstances call into question the authenticity of the transactions between the Defendant and Coastal Oil (which formed the basis of Coastal Oil’s Financing Applications with the Plaintiff),” stated the bank.
“Further, it lends itself to the possibility that the Defendant is part of a broader conspiracy with Coastal Oil.
“However, I am advised and verily believe that the Plaintiff requires additional documents before it is able to come to a firm landing as to whether it should commence action against the Defendant.”
DBS request for payment results in validity dispute
DBS sought payment from Sinfeng after Coastal Oil underwent voluntary liquidation on 13 December 2018 by sending a request to ask payment for US$27,190,988.28 from Sinfeng on 19 December 2018 regarding three contacts.
On 26 December 2018, the bank however received a letter from Sinfeng disputing the validity of the three contracts.
According to the bank, the Sinfeng contracts were affixed by its authorised representative, namely Liang Yu Wei (Mr Liang), with the company’s seal. However, further communication between DBS and Sinfeng suggested of Coastal Oil allegedly being in possession of Mr Liang’s signature stamp.
“The Defendant did not proffer any explanation as to how Coastal Oil would have come into possession of Mr Liang’s signature stamp, since Mr Liang was an authorised representative of the Defendant,” stated DBS.
“Even if the Sinfeng Contracts are revealed to be sham contracts as the Defendant claims, it would no doubt have been difficult for Coastal Oil to duplicate Mr Liang’s signature stamp without additional help.”
Reasons behind application for pre-action discovery
DBS alleged Sinfeng to date has not provided “any assistance” into the matter to ascertain whether the Sinfeng Contracts are genuine; as such, it is seeking pre-action discovery of the relevant documents to do so.
“I understand that based on the available facts, the Plaintiff believes that it potentially has a claim against the Defendant as an assignee of receivables under the Sinfeng Contracts, for fraudulent misrepresentation and/or conspiracy,” stated DBS.
“However, the Plaintiff is not in a position to commence proceedings yet as it presently has insufficient facts to mount a claim.”
The bank added: “If the Sinfeng Contracts are genuine, then the Plaintiff may proceed against the Defendant for failing to make payment under the Assignment.”
“On the other hand, if the Sinfeng Contracts are found to be sham contracts, then the Plaintiff may take action against the Defendant for losses suffered on account of the fraud perpetrated on the Plaintiff and/or the fraudulent misrepresentation exercised on the Plaintiff when the Defendant signed the Acknowledgements.”
A complete coverage of the events leading to the current development has been arranged by Singapore bunker publication Manifold Times (in descending date order) below:
Related: Sinfeng Marine wins appeal to withhold additional documents from Coastal Oil liquidators
Related: Sinfeng appeals against release of Coastal Oil contract docs; China Merchants Bank suspects fraud
Related: Singapore: Former Coastal Oil employees face forgery charges over fake sales contracts
Related: Coastal Oil hearings progress, court grants liquidators access to Sinfeng documents
Related: China Merchants Bank legal suit with Sinfeng over alleged $13 million debt progresses
Related: Fraud suspected in Coastal Oil Singapore case, says COSCO
Related: Coastal Logistics owned “Atalanta”, “Babylon” to undergo auction
Related: Singapore: Bunker tanker “Coastal Mercury” arrested
Related: Heng Tong Fuels & Shipping in court over DBS Bank bunker tanker loan
Related: Coastal Logistics owned MR tanker “Babylon” arrested
Related: Fraud suspected in Coastal Oil Singapore case, says COSCO
Related: Coastal Oil Singapore: Creditor list surfaces in bunker market
Related: Singapore: Bunker tanker “Coastal Neptune” arrested
Related: Coastal Oil Singapore creditors meeting scheduled on 10 Jan
Related: Coastal Oil Singapore in US $380 million debt to at least 10 banks
Related: Singapore: Coastal Logistics owned MR tanker “Atalanta” arrested
Related: Heng Tong Fuels & Shipping, Coastal Logistics tankers enter S&P market
Related: Coastal Oil Singapore to hold creditors meeting on 28 Dec
Related: Breaking news: Coastal Oil Singapore under liquidation
Photo credit: Manifold Times
Published: 20 April, 2021
Significant uptick in the number of quality claims being alleged by ship owners has also been seen since the implementation of contactless bunkering operations, notes Partner at Rajah & Tann.
‘The launch of our company website signifies the readiness of Singfar to engage with relevant stakeholders to achieve our mission of enabling sustainable trade,’ Managing Director tells Manifold Times.
Associate Director at Helmsman highlights the need to stay up-to-date with latest protocols / measures introduced by MPA, with continuous education of Master and crew of the visiting vessel.
BunkerPlanner Lite is an attempt to educate professionals engaged in bunker decisions about the use of advanced technology in the decision process, explains BunkerMetric CEO Christian Plum.
Senior Associate at Clyde & Co offers guidance to protect shipowners and bunker tanker operators in the event opposing counterparty breaches Covid-19 protocols, resulting in Covid-19 transmission.
Having a surveyor’s watchful eye to detect illegal activities also sends a strong signal to barge and vessel crew not to undertake any intended non-compliance, states VPS Senior Sales Manager.