The bunker balance – owners consider LNG in advance of 2020
The following article is written by Eleanor Midwinter and Ina Lutchmiah of international law firm Wikborg Rein, and shared with Singapore bunker publication Manifold Times:
Using LNG rather than fuel oil is one of a range of options available to owners seeking to comply with IMO 2020. Given that shipbrokers have long predicted the emergence of a two-tier shipping market with 'greener' ships commanding a premium over older less eco-friendly vessels, what then is the future for LNG bunkering and what challenges does it present?
The shipping trade press initially took a somewhat pessimistic view of LNG bunkering as a solution to the IMO 2020 problem with forecasts suggesting that high costs and technical difficulties would present a commercial barrier to LNG bunkering being adopted across the industry. Despite the forecasts however, in the past year we have seen an interesting series of "world firsts" for new-build and retro-fitted LNG powered vessels in different sectors including cruise ships, ferries and more general commercial carriers. For example, Maritime Executive reported in March of this year on the retrofitting of the "SAJIR", which will be the first mega-container vessel to be converted to a dual-fuel system. Various innovations are also underway, including Cryo Shipping's conversion of platform supply vessels into LNG tankers for STS supplies, which may help ease congestion at LNG bunker ports or provide supplies in areas not serviced by such ports. These reports, together with commitments from large owners such as CMA CGM and MSC, suggest that owners may be more receptive to LNG bunkering than was initially expected. The world fleet of LNG powered has jumped in size since 2017 from 118 vessels to 143 vessels, with around 135 LNG-powered vessels also on order (Source: Maritime Executive as previous).
Whether owners choose to adopt LNG bunkering as a solution to the IMO 2020 problem or adopt one of the other available options such as using low sulphur fuel or installing scrubbers depends on a myriad of factors with owners adopting different solutions, sometimes even within their own fleets. This is essentially because there is no perfect solution. Owners have needed to be sensitive to trading patterns and available infrastructure. Using low sulphur fuel leaves owners at the mercy of oil and freight volatility. Scrubber retrofits may not provide a fully predictable outcome – with new geographical restraints having emerged since their introduction – including the ban on open loop scrubbers in Singapore, China and Fujairah, and the anticipated ban in the Norwegian fjords. Likewise, given the high cost of LNG retrofitting, it would not make sense to undertake it on vessels close to scrapping age or those operating without ready access to LNG bunkering ports. LNG bunkering is therefore best suited for owners ready to invest in new vessels, or for retrofitting less elderly vessels which will operate in areas where there is existing LNG bunkering infrastructure, such as Northern Europe.
A report from Jack Sharples of the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies had this to say in his 2019 report on LNG bunkering: "…the introduction of more stringent environmental regulations can solve the ‘chicken and egg’ dilemma of energy companies not wishing to invest in LNG bunkering infrastructure until there is substantial demand for LNG as a marine fuel". This seems to be reflected in the increased activity in projects to support LNG bunkering not only in areas traditionally supplying LNG but across many major transport hubs. This means that LNG fuelled vessels will likely become far more attractive to owners.
But for vessels already on the water, what issues does a retrofit present? One perhaps unforeseen issue is that IMO 2020 has added to tightening of availability at shipyards for retrofit solutions. The resulting pressure to move quickly to secure slots leads to negotiating constraints. This impacts on timing and cost and can also create legal problems. Often, there is a shift in bargaining power from owners to the yard in times of high demand and less attention is paid to the finer points of contract drafting. We see the effects of this in an increasing number of disputes and difficulties under retrofit contracts and related charters. Owners should therefore keep in mind that a retrofit contract requires consideration of similar issues to a full shipbuilding or conversion contract with special attention needing to be paid to items that are likely to impact on earnings under associated vessel charters, such as the warranty for the work (including where warranty work can be done), the amount of liquidated damages and related delay provisions. Clarity, as always, is key. Where there needs to be flexibility, such as for modifications and regulatory change, this must be supported by appropriately drafted triggers for change, remedies and dispute resolution procedures. Any existing charter obligations must be reviewed and added to as needed, for example, to deal with anticipated unexpected loss of use of the vessel.
There will also be different safety procedures to take into account, for example, ISO 20519:2017 (Ships and marine technology – Specification for bunkering of liquefied natural gas fuelled vessels) and the IGF Code (International Code of Safety for Ship Using Gases or Other Low-flashpoint Fuels). Both are designed to provide standards for ships operating using gas i.e., as a fuel, whether newly built or converted, rather than being aimed at more traditional gas carriers.
Finally, owners/charterers will need to be prepared for reviewing new bunker contracts. Traditionally, contracts for the sale and purchase of LNG are more detail oriented than say, heavy fuel oil contracts. One option is to adapt existing bunker agreements that owners/charterers are already comfortable with, but this does require specialist drafting. Specifications and tolerances will need to be updated. Attention also needs to be paid to LNG-specific terms, such as transfer of title for return vapour, commingling considerations, the effect of off-specification gas, and related operational issues. Help may soon be at hand however from BIMCO, who announced that they would be working on a new LNG Bunker Purchase Contract and LPG voyage charter for the Asian market as of January 2019. This is expected to be ready for publication within 18 months. Whether or not an owners' organisation can create a form that finds favour with brokers and suppliers has yet to be seen. In the meantime, we have specialist trading and LNG lawyers available to assist with bespoke solutions and contract reviews.
We will be watching with interest to see the extent to which LNG bunkering continues to be adopted by the industry and the impact this has on spot trading of LNG and of course hire rates for LNG carriers and LNG fuelled vessels and will report back on this in further issues of Update.
Source: Wikborg Rein
Published: 12 July, 2019
AET and TOTAL sign time charter agreement for two LNG dual-fuel VLCCs
Both newbuildings will be amongst the most environmentally friendly VLCCs around, as they emit 20% less CO2 GHGs, 85% less NOx and 99% less SOx than conventional vessels.
Wärtsilä: Cutting greenhouse gas emissions from LNG engines
As uptake of LNG accelerates, its impact on emissions is widely debated due to methane slips; Wärtsilä demonstrates how technology can make LNG a viable bunkering option.
CMAL: KC LNG awarded Scotland’s first LNG bunkering facilities
Facilities will be operated by CalMac on behalf of CMAL and are expected to be ready for operations in 2022 as part of major upgrade works at Uig and Ardrossan harbours.
Sinanju Tankers Holdings and other shipping firms join SGMF in Q1
Corsica Linea, Gothia Tanker Alliance, MISC Berhad, Sinanju Tankers Holdings Pte Ltd, and Wessels Marine GmbH joins over a hundred other SGMF members.
CIMC Raffles begins construction of world’s largest LNG-powered mega RoRo Vessel
The first of two vessels, with an option of two more, will be equipped with two Type C LNG bunker fuel tanks and are designed to meet Finnish-Swedish ice class 1A Super standards.
SGMF video explains why LNG as marine fuel can cut emissions from shipping
Video describes how LNG can provide a clear pathway to fuels, enabling industry to meet the IMO target to reduce GHG emissions by at least 50% by 2050.
Nauticor partners Novatek in LNG bunkering development at Baltic Sea
With strengths in their respective regions, the coalition is a progression to benefit companies that choose LNG as their bunkering option in the Baltic Sea.
Singapore: Seven Yield delivers first deep sea LNG-fuelled car carrier “Siem Confucius”
A comprehensive LNG bunkering fuel supply agreement has been signed with Shell to guarantee that all Volkswagen Group voyages will utilise exclusively LNG fuel.
Shipyard achieves milestone in construction of world’s largest LNG dual-fuel boxship
Jiangnan Shipbuilding positioned the CMA CGM vessel’s 2,200 mt engine and other components in record time with five large cranes and an approximate hundred smaller units.
CSSC completes sea trials for LNG-ready SK Marine VLOC
Trials successfully executed despite the COVID-19 pandemic through careful planning and remote electronic communications; estimated delivery by end of April.
Gasum to supply LNG biogas marine fuel blend to Preen time-chartered tankers
Vessels that will be supplied with Gasum’s blend of renewable maritime fuel are the time-chartered tankers Tern Ocean and Thun Evolve.
China: CIMC enters emerging market of LNG fuel tanks for luxury cruise ships
Despite many difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the company managed to gain customer confidence and cinch two deals worth RMB 160 million, it said.
Titan LNG bunker deliveries resume in North West Europe despite COVID-19
Titan LNG to monitor COVID-19 situation based on approved guidelines and situation reports in order to optimise normal working rhythms and a healthy economy.
SEA\LNG welcomes Stabilis Energy as newest member
Stabilis supplies LNG for use in marine bunkering services, as well as other industrial sectors.
SEA\LNG welcomes Port of Virginia as first U.S. port to membership
In March 2019, the port established a working group to examine the benefit and scalability of LNG bunkers.
SEA\LNG: LNG a viable pathway to meeting IMO 2050 GHG targets
‘LNG offers a commercially viable long-term bridging solution to addressing the IMO GHG targets,’ says Chairman.
SEA\LNG sums up 2018 LNG bunkering developments, provides forecast
‘If 2018 was the tipping point for LNG as a marine fuel, 2019 will be the year of acceleration,’ says Chairman.
MPA, Société Générale appointed as board members of SEA\LNG
‘I am delighted to welcome Paul and Capt Segar as representatives from these organisations,’ says Chairman.
SEA\LNG welcomes Skangas as latest member
Skangas is a provider of LNG in Northern Europe and operates the LNG bunkering vessel Coralius.
SEA\LNG welcomes ÉNESTAS to LNG bunkering coalition
The largest private LNG business in Mexico boosts SEALNG’s presence in the Americas.
SEA\LNG reiterates benefits of LNG as marine fuel
Alternative fuels not economic, not available at scale, and unproven for shipping operations, it says.
SEA\LNG: Building the momentum for LNG as a marine fuel
Chairman provides an update on the emissions, investment, and infrastructure front of LNG bunkers.
SEA\LNG welcomes MAN Diesel & Turbo to membership
The organisation’s knowledge base is boosted with addition of newest member, says SEALNG.
SEA\LNG publishes case study on LNG bunkering ship
Study discusses bunker vessel design, regulations, customer confidence, and LNG knowledge.
SEA\LNG: Norway’s domestic carbon tax on LNG ‘unhelpful’
Tax likely lead to an increase in emissions of climate gases, NOX, sulphur and particulate matter.
SEA\LNG reiterates LNG’s role in shipping carbon free future
‘LNG has unmatchable major local emissions benefits and is a major step forward for GHG reductions,’ it says.
“K” Line and Uyeno Group join SEA\LNG
‘Our members in Japan are doing important work, both in the region and across the world,’ says SEALNG chairman.
Vancouver joins forces with Tomakomai for LNG Bunkering
Partnership aims to help reduce shipping emissions through LNG bunkering while enabling the adoption of LNG as marine fuel for ships engaged along the trans-Pacific route.
Successful first LNG Bunkering operation at Klaipėdos, Lithuania
‘The whole process was complicated by the fact that there is no legislation regulating LNG bunkering in Lithuania today,’ says Director General of Klaipėdos Nafta.
Poseidon Med II: LNG as maritime fuel in Eastern Mediterranean sea
First post-IMO 2020 conference in Piraeus highlights the port’s key competitive advantages in LNG bunkering that could set the tone for the region.
Wärtsilä to supply cargo handling system to LNG Bunkering vessel
18,000 cbm LNG bunkering vessel built for Korea Line at Hyundai Mipo Dockyard; contract includes option for second vessel.
SEA\LNG commissioned study highlights strong ROI for LNG-fuelled bulk carrier
Study outlines commercial benefits for 210K DWT Ore Carrier on a basis over 10 years along Australia China route.
Shell LNG Outlook 2020 - LNG as marine fuel to quadruple by 2040
Demand expected to accelerate as LNG bunkering infrastructure develops, and more LNG-fuelled ships are ordered.
Nauticor in partnership to provide LNG bunker fuel to Fassmer Shipyard projects
First LNG bunkering operation in new cooperation was carried out for research vessel Atait on 6 February.
Wärtsilä obtains DNV GL type approval for SceneScan position system
World’s first laser-based targetless relative DP reference system on LNG bunker tanker Kairos helps to enable safe bunkering at sea.
SEA\LNG shares ‘View from the Bridge’ of LNG marine fuel growth in 2019/2020
Report tracks LNG-fuelled growth in vessel segments and worldwide expansion and development of LNG bunkering infrastructure along key trade lanes.
Sovcomflot committing to LNG as primary fuel for large-capacity oil tankers
‘The company expects all vessels it orders to be using LNG as marine fuel, except where a charterer specifically asks to do otherwise,’ says Igor Tonkovidov.
KNOT awarded long-term charters for two LNG-powered shuttle tankers
KNOT to build two 124,000 dwt LNG-fuelled shuttle tankers at Daewoo Shipping to meet ENI operation requirements in the North Sea.
CMA CGM Group enters GTT service package for LNG-fuelled boxships
The GTT services portfolio facilitates ship-owners’ entry into the world of using LNG as bunker fuel, says company Chairman and CEO.
NYK orders second LNG-fuelled pure car and truck carrier (PCTC) from Japanese shipyard
Order placed with Shin Kurushima Dockyard Co. Ltd. as NYK aims to provide more low emissions transportation options with LNG-fuelled technology.
Port of Antwerp welcomes first ship-to-ship LNG Bunkering operation
Operation carried out by Dutch LNG supplier Titan LNG and is a crucial step towards achieving Antwerp’s goal of being a “Multi Fuel Port”.
DNV GL launches ‘FuelBoss’ - an integrated hub for LNG Bunkering
Platform aims to integrate a growing, but fragmented LNG bunkering market by simplifying daily operations on both supply and demand side.
First STS LNG bunkering operation completed for DEME-owned “Orion” at Rostock
Nauticor’s Kairos successfully supplied next generation offshore installation vessel Orion, the fifth dual fuel vessel in DEME’s fleet, with LNG.
SEA\LNG and SGMF respond to ICCT negative analysis of LNG as marine fuel
Associations not contacted prior to release of ICCT report and need time to review document in depth; but stands behind Thinkstep study.
Japan's first LNG-fuelled vessel “Sakigake” reaches 100th LNG bunkering milestone
LNG bunkering was conducted safely and efficiently from a tank truck at the No. 5 quay of Shinko, Yokohama.
AG&P expands business to include small-scale bunker vessels and LNG-to-power barges
Atlantic Gulf and Pacific are reaching smaller and more scattered customers through its distribution solutions that drive down the delivered cost of LNG.
Greece: EUR 20 million finance agreement signed for construction of new LNG bunker vessel
Greece’s first LNG bunker vessel will be supplied with LNG at Revithoussa LNG terminal and will refuel ships both in Piraeus and other ports in Greece and the wider region.
ICCT analysis points to ‘damning climate indictment of LNG as marine fuel’, says Stand.earth
ICCT report indicates the predominantly-methane-based LNG marine fuel traps 86 times more heat in the atmosphere than the same amount of CO2 over a 20-year time period.
Hyundai’s shop test of dual-fuel engine 11G90ME-GI successfully runs on 100% gas
ME-GI engine features MAN Energy Solutions' new PBIV, which reduces pilot-oil consumption to just 1.5%, approximately half of what was previously required.
Gassum reports increased business as “Coralius” completes 200th STS LNG bunkering op
Coralius’s first bunkering was in September 2017; she reached the 100th bunkering mark in February last year; her 200th delivery was achieved this week, says the company.
LNG-powered “Viking Energy” to undergo ammonia powered fuel cell conversion
Viking Energy will have a large 2MW ammonia fuel cell retrofitted, allowing it to sail solely on the clean fuel for up to 3,000 hours annually.
Probunkers signs LOI with Hyundai for construction of two LNG bunker vessels
‘Hyundai is among the very few yards which can demonstrate experience in the new field of LNG bunker ship design and construction,’ says Probunkers.
Wärtsilä launches LNG Bunkering & Fuel Supply System Simulator to raise training levels
Simulator design is based on Wärtsilä LNGPac and Gas Valve Unit technologies, and in accordance with the STCW requirements demanded by the international code of safety.
Cryostar and KC LNG to upgrade bunkering facility at Antwerp port
Development allows Fluxys, G&V, Titan LNG and Rolande to offer LNG as marine fuel at quay 526/528, where now only truck-to-ship bunkering is taking place.
Port of Rotterdam: LNG bunkering ops up in 2019, to introduce bunker permit by 2021
Three permanent LNG bunker vessels operating in port to date, with further four LNG bunkering specialists owning LNG bunkering licence.
2019 - A good year for LNG as marine fuel, says Wessel Marine
Generated savings for bunker costs (LNG versus MGO) of LNG-retrofitted Wes Amelie was approximately 2.750 EUR per day and almost one million EUR in 2019.
Wärtsilä customises LNG solution for four next-generation short-sea cargo vessels
Wärtsilä develops a customised solution that allow its LNGPac storage and supply system to be installed below deck without compromising the cargo hold space.
Sovcomflot LNG-fuelled tankers start construction at Zvezga shipyard
Rosnefteflot studies possibility of expanding the line of MR class vessels by another three units, it says.
Cosco Shipping Energy upgrades VLCC order to DF LNG-fuelled unit
Firm will pay an additional USD 6 million to Dalian Shipbuilding, with delivery delayed by nine months.
MOL orders two LNG-fuelled ferries from Mitsubishi Shipbuilding
Successive completion and handover for the first of such ferries scheduled from end of 2022 to early 2023.
Kyushu Electric Power to deploy LNG-fuelled large coal carriers
Both vessels, each from NYK and MOL, will receive LNG bunker fuel from a Kyuden subsidiary LNG firm.
Mitsubishi Shipbuilding delivers FGSS for LNG-fuelled PCC
Vessel is currently under construction at the Shin Kurushima Toyohashi Shipbuilding facility at Toyohashi.
Titan LNG conducts first LNG bunkering operation at Port of Brest
LNG fuel supplier delivered bunkers to hopper dredger Scheldt River in a truck-to-ship refuelling operation.
MOL secures BNPP and CEXIM ‘green loan’ to build LNG bunker tanker
18,600 cbm LNG bunkering vessel will operate in northern Europe to supply LNG for Containerships’s vessels.
Pavilion Energy and TMFGS enter 10-year LNG bunkering agreement
Firms to share use of LNG bunker tanker and develop an LNG bunker supply chain in the port of Singapore.
SBBT prototype LNG bunkering vessel assigned for construction
Dual product vessel that will mainly operate in the North-Adriatic Sea is scheduled for delivery in 2020.
Greek Public Gas Corporation issues tender for LNG bunkering vessels
Two LNG bunkering vessels, one for DEPA and one for NAVIGAS, will operate at Piraeus and Limassol port.
CMA CGM Group subsidiary receives fourth box ship powered by LNG
The 1,380 TEU Containerships Arctic will receive 200 mt of LNG via ship-to-ship bunkering at Rotterdam.
Singapore: Earlier court judgement between Hanwa and Harley Marine discharged
Hanwa obtained judgement following an “Emergency Arbitration” application on 18 July 2018 to prevent the risk of dissipation by the former Singapore-based bunkering firms.
BP Singapore bunker trial nears end as legal reps present summary submissions
Lawyers of the ex-Regional Marine Manager of BP Singapore, the Executive Director of Pacific Prime Trading, and Deputy Public Prosecutors were present at the State Courts on Wednesday.
Vitol Group acquires Sinanju Tankers Holdings; gains foothold in Singapore bunker ops
The Singapore Bunkering license holding entity has been renamed Vitol Bunkers (S) Pte Ltd and from 1 April 2020 all bunker deliveries will be carried out by Vitol Bunkers (S) Pte Ltd.
PMI Trading responds to Nustar Energy over alleged off-spec bunker fuel supply at Houston
Seeks to enforce either arbitration clause under contract or to dismiss NuStar and TPP respective liability claims, according to documents obtained by Manifold Times.
‘Minimal disruption’ to Singapore bunkering operations despite COVID-19, confirms MPA
‘We are closely monitoring the rapidly developing COVID-2019 situation while remaining committed to working with the bunkering industry to ensure minimal disruption to bunkering operations and services.’
Photo Essay: “Marine Vicky” in multi-agency emergency preparedness exercise at Singapore port
The emergency preparedness exercise involving SCDF, PCG, MPA, and Sinanju was carried out on the LNG dual-fuel bunker tanker at Raffles Anchorage on 17 March, learned Manifold Times.