A Judge at the State Courts of the Republic of Singapore on 9 June issued the Director of Seahub Energy Pte Ltd a 35-month imprisonment sentence, due to his role in a conspiracy to tamper with the mass flowmetering (MFM) systems on board Singapore bunker tankers Southernpec 6 and Southernpec 7 between October 2018 to April 2019.
During the period of offence, Eric Ang Heng Lye was employed as a consultant at Ocean Express Pte Ltd; around June 2018, Ang was acting as a consultant and partner of Success Energy Service Pte Ltd.
Ang pleaded guilty to 14 charges under s 7(1)(b) read with s 10(1) of the Computer Misuse Act (Cap 50A, Rev. Ed. 2007) (CMA); and (b) 1 charge under s 204A read with s. 109 of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev. Ed.).
Discovery of offences
Court documents obtained by Singapore bunkering publication Manifold Times showed a Maritime and Port Authority (MPA) Port Inspector boarding the Southernpec 7 during a routine patrol on 19 April 2019.
The Port Inspector found a magnet attached to the bunker tanker’s MFM and subsequently alerted the Police Coast Guard; the authorities later decided to also investigate Southernpec 6 due to it being a sistership of Southernpec 7.
A request by the authorities to have the MFM vendor review data from the bunker metering computer (BMC) on both vessels found at least 66 separate bunkering operations during which the MFM was tampered with.
Summary of conspiracy
In June 2018, Success Energy started running bunkering operations for New Ocean Fuel Pte Ltd which chartered Southernpec 6 and Southernpec 7 for the delivery of marine fuel.
During this time, Success Energy instructed its cargo officers to use an industrial strength magnet to tamper with the MFM on board the Southernpec bunker tankers during bunkering operations for New Ocean.
To avoid detection, they would use tape that had the same colour as the surface of the MFM to disguise the use of the magnet on the MFM.
The purpose of using a magnet to tamper with the MFM is to cause a higher amount of bunker fuel to be recorded on the BMC as having been delivered to the buyer vessel than what was actually delivered; it therefore helped New Ocean to “save” on the bunkers delivered.
Court documents noted an accomplice of Ang collecting at least $40,000 per month from New Ocean for bunker fuel saved through the use of the magnet.
On average, the accomplice will pay cargo officers $50 for every metric tonne (mt) of bunkers saved. The cargo officers received at least $4,000 per month with some up to $11,000 per month, in addition to their base salary of $2,500.
“The estimated total value of MFO which was erroneously recorded as having been delivered to the receiving vessels across the 14 proceeded CMA charges is US$121,585.60,” stated the document.
“The estimated total value of the MFO across all 66 CMA charges (including those which have been taken into consideration) is US$336,930.63.”
A summary of the 14 CMA charges is as follows:
|CMA Charge///||Undelivered Fuel to Vessel///||Value of Undelivered Fuel|
|01||16.7 mt to Sakizaya Ace||USD 7,114.20|
|02||27.1 mt to Teton||USD 11,327.80|
|03||22.6 mt to Dawn||USD 8,859.20|
|04||13.5 mt to Antarctic||USD 4,671.00|
|05||21.7 mt to Tasos||USD 8,202.60|
|06||21.6 mt to Cronus Leader||USD 8,078.40|
|07||35.5 mt to Angelic Glory||USD 15,052.00|
|08||21.0 mt to Snowy||USD 8,386.90|
|09||21,6 mt to PVT Sapphire||USD 8,510.40|
|10||22.0 mt to Ocean Marvel||USD 8,613.00|
|11||34.7 mt to Ocean Paradise||USD 13,533.00|
|12||10.6 mt to Fortune Glory||USD 3,678.20|
|13||19.8 mt to STI Manhattan||USD 8,385.30|
|14||16.8 mt to Dato Fortune||USD 7,173.60|
The above article is the latest in the series of ‘Magnets on MFMs’ articles written by Manifold Times; earlier stories related to the development are as follows:
Related: Magnets on MFMs: Trial ends with ten-month imprisonment for Bunker Clerk of “Fragrance”
Related: Magnets on MFMs: Driver posed as Southernpec bunker crew to commit MFM tampering
Related: Magnets on MFMs: Trial starts for former bunker clerk of “Consort Justice”
Related: Magnets on MFMs: First suspect charged over MFM tampering in landmark case
Related: Magnets on MFMs: “Consort Justice” crew pleads ‘not guilty’ to tampering charge
Related: Singapore: Southernpec bunker supplier licence revoked by MPA
Related: Official: MPA revokes Southernpec bunker craft operator licence
Related: Magnets on MFMs: MPA suspends Southernpec bunker craft license
Related: Magnets on MFMs: Case of ‘a few bad apples spoiling the basket’
Related: Magnets on MFMs: Issue a breach of ‘Operational Security’ under TR 48 (updated)
Related: Singapore: Sea Hub Energy exits MPA bunker craft operator list
Photo credit: Manifold Times
Published: 23 June, 2021
Session will provide insights on bunker quality issues from a bunker supplier, shipping company and surveyor, as well as providing insight and guidance on legal and dispute resolution issues.
Gealubes Consulting & Trading, the authorised marine business distributor of PANOLIN EALs at Singapore port, shares a two-part education series on Environmentally Acceptable Lubricants on Manifold Times.
Danny Lee Chee Keong was sentenced to nine months’ imprisonment over the theft of MFO from the Consort Bunkers owned and operated bunker tanker at the sea off Eastern Petroleum ‘B’ anchorage.
‘Metcore’s MFM+ Program exemplifies serious oil suppliers and buyers who advocate fair trading using a recognised and widely-accepted technology,’ highlights Darrick Pang, Managing Director of Metcore.
‘The victim is Consort Bunkers Pte Ltd, the owner of the Pearl Melody,’ states the joint statement of facts (SOF) document obtained by Singapore bunkering publication Manifold Times.
Between November 2016 and October 2017, Mr Tan falsified at least 20 invoices and submitted these invoices to UOB and OCBC, according to court documents obtained by bunkering publication Manifold Times.